Here are the boys from the 90's that have been suggested so far - pretty good selection I think.
First up is the poster boy for good moral judgement (with a minor alcohol problem along the way) - Mr Brandon Walsh..
followed by the boy we all wanted to fix - Mr Dillon McKay
Next we have the underlord of dark and brooding - ANGEL
And the fun loving prankster forever in Dawson's shadow - Mr Pacey Witter
and last but not least the head of the cheery Salinger family - Mr Charlie Sallinger.
They were all so cute I had to show you a shot of each to help with the decision making...